groups flourish as lower-priced acts
Vocal sounds from Motown's
glory days find their own
venues no matter what
By MIKE WEATHERFORD
LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
Are there enough matching
jackets to go around?
The oldies vocal groups have
invaded. For whatever reason, we woke up last week and found ourselves
surrounded by synchronized dance steps and four-part harmonies.
This is a Las Vegas phenomenon
that's rarely discussed outside of litigation over who can call themselves
the Platters, Drifters and Coasters.
The lawsuits wouldn't exist
if there wasn't a proven audience for classic songs from the '50s through
the mid-'70s, as long as they're delivered with showmanship and a certain
At the very least, shows
such as Fourever Tops at the Riviera are harmless lounge tributes. Occasionally,
one rises above the standard rehash, such as former Temptations Glenn Leonard
and Ali Woodson, trying to revive a near-forgotten showroom at the Lady
Somewhere in the middle lies
a package that draws its strength from its collective musical history.
It's hard to keep count of the hits in the triple-bill of Platters/Coasters/Drifters
music that returned last week to the Sahara, where it proved to be a long-term
commodity a few years ago.
Never mind that Cornell Gunter,
of Cornell Gunter's Coasters, is dead. So, for that matter, is Beary Hobbs,
of Beary Hobbs' Drifters. There are seasoned showmen in both acts who will
pass the scrutiny of all but the serious musicologist.
Forget that frontman Early
Clover isn't Gunter but his cousin. Or that Gunter himself didn't join
the original Coasters until a year after their breakthrough single, "Searchin'
What matters is Clover working
the room during the "gonna find her" part of the song, soliciting handshakes
and kisses with his animated face and comic persona. If you didn't know
better -- and I'm willing to bet a lot of people in the room don't -- you'd
think you were in the presence of someone famous.
There's a similar authority
in the Hobbs' Drifters. Jerome Jackson sang with Hobbs for years and does
standout work with "Up on the Roof" and "Spanish Harlem," even if he sounds
more like Lou Rawls than the original singles.
The Platters -- not to be
confused with Monroe Powell's group at the Seven restaurant -- get to keep
the name without a modifier, thanks to a licensing agreement. Again there's
a certain legitimacy earned from experience; one of the four singers, Christy
Brooks, has ties to the original Platters that stem back 36 years.
These Platters have the confidence
to venture from the essentials, going off the path for Brooks to sing "Someone
to Watch Over Me" or Dereck Jackson's florid piano introduction to "My
Prayer." But they tend to push the showmanship too far.
The show closes Sunday and
returns Jan. 13 for an indefinite run. All three acts will then get time
to smooth things out with their shared four-piece band.
A sparse band is better than
none at all, as evidenced by "Fourever Tops: A Tribute to the Four Tops
and The Temptations," one of many acts sharing the LeBistro cabaret at
The hotel finally got around
to glassing in the former lounge that now hosts ticketed acts. Too bad
for this group, which might make sense as one of those "free"-for-a-$5.95
drink promotions, but doesn't cut it as a $25.25 ticket.
The problem isn't so much
the quartet, which offers likable stage patter and passable renditions
of Four Tops hits, albeit overly mannered ones that lack the real group's
The real drain is the brutally
bad taped music. I've said this before: If you have to use a tape, at least
pay for a real band once to record it.
The Motown legacy is, however,
in good hands with Leonard and Woodson, billed under the legally correct-but-cumbersome
handle, "Reunion of the Legendary Lead Singers of the Temptations."
The four singers working
with Leonard have their own gravity that quickly erases any issues of legitimacy.
Leonard joined The Temptations in 1975, past the group's real glory days,
while Woodson came even later; he played Las Vegas with the real group
as late as 1995.
But these guys hit the stage
like they mean business, and generate some massive harmonies.
And here again, the music
makes a substantial difference. Musical director Ron Hasley sits at a grand
piano and whips a local quartet into dynamic, back-to-back renditions of
"Get Ready" and "Papa Was a Rolling Stone."
But those songs come after
"The Fantasticks" standard "Try to Remember," an unusual introduction that
allows Leonard to demonstrate that his impressive falsetto is untarnished
by the years, and signals a few surprises to come.
Midway through, Leonard yields
the stage and backing singers to Woodson, who was battling Vegas throat
on Sunday night, but still managed to make the most of his 1984 Temptations
hit, "Treat Her Like a Lady."
The show came to a full two
hours, counting a 25-minute set by another licensed trio, the Marvelettes.
It's refreshing to violate the usual 90-minute law, even if some of the
audience participation shtick did run on.
But at $37.95, it's a relative
bargain if anyone bothers to look for the venue; a "temporary" building
that's been there for years. Fear not. It's been given a good cleaning,
not to mention new lights, carpet and sound equipment.
The Temptations singers stay
through Sunday, then return Jan. 14 for what they hope will be a long run
in a room that, like most of the vocal groups, prove you're only as old
as you feel.
This article originally
appeared in the December, 1999 issue of The Archive News magazine. To receive
a print copy of the magazine, and this article complete with photographs,
please contact Celebrity Direct Magazine at CDE@CelebrityDirect.net
by Cord G. Coslor
have recorded nearly 400 songs, have sold over 100 million copies of those
songs, and have performed throughout the world, winning many awards and
an induction into the Rock And Roll Hall of Fame along the way. The Platters,
over the years, have appeared in 27 movies such as "Rock Around The Clock,"
"Girl's Town," "Europe By Night," and many more. Some of their most memorable
and well-known songs include The Great Pretender, (You’ve Got) The Magic
Touch, Only You (And You Alone), and Twilight Time.
But who exactly
are The Platters? After reading this article, you will discover there any
many groups using the name “Platters” in some form or another. Some of
these groups consist of original members of The Platters, but many or most
do not. Some of these groups are related to the original Platters management,
some are not. We believe it is important to be able to distiguish “real
Platters” from the fakes and the frauds.... as a fan of The Platters or
as a collector of Platters music memorabilia.
Since the 1950s,
The Platters have undergone a myriad of changes. Changes in which have,
at times, made this group difficult to keep track of, understand personnel
changes, and find accurate and truthful information on. This article is
intended to tell the story of The Platters... a story of classic
hits, world fame, and success. It will also present the unfortunate other
side to the story: group division, legal battles, and ugly lawsuits. Most
importantly, using personal testaments from many involved with the
group such as management, and the members themselves, the author hopes
to tell these stories in an honest and truthful manner! But, with each
side telling their own version of the story, you will find many contradictory
statements and supposed “fact” about The Platters history. The author is
merely a laison between actual performers and management from over the
years, to you, the reader. The author makes no claim as to being a judge,
nor a lawyer, and leaves the job of jury to the reader and fan.
This is their
of 1953, four men converged on Los Angeles to form a group for competing
in local amateur shows, etc. This early group consisted of Cornell
Gunther, Alex Hodge, Herb Reed, and Joe Jefferson. The Platters name
was derived from the popular term used by DJs when refering to records,
says Herb Reed. These were times of high school friends playing for their
peers, a time of innocense. They didn’t know about money, recording albums,
or the problems that were yet to come in future years. Herb Reed said in
a recent interview, “We were just kids still in school performing popular
songs of the day... harmonizing. No thoughts of hit records, no thoughts
With both Reed
and Gunther singing lead, the men won several amateur contests and appeared
on The Ebony Showcase, a television program. Soon, David Lynch replaced
Joe Jefferson, and the legendary Tony Williams joined the group while Cornell
Gunther (later famous with The Flairs and The Coasters) departed. At this
point, Ralph Bass of Federal Records signed the group to their first recording
That same year,
a songwriter from Chicago named Buck Ram signed a management contract
with the group. The members at that time were Herb Reed, David Lynch, Tony
Williams, and Alex Hodge. Early in 1954, the same time Ram decided a female
would be a good addition to the group, Zola Taylor was at Alex Hodge's
house rehearsing with Cornell Gunther's sister, Shirley Gunther.
Both ladies were with the Queens at this time. Soon, Zola was taken
onboard The Platters, and in the same year Paul Robi replaced Alex Hodge.
Buck Ram and
The Platters really got rolling when Ram was negotiating a deal with Mercury
Records for another one of his groups, The Penguins. At this time, The
Penguins' song, "Earth Angel" was at the top of the charts in the United
States. Ram was negotiating a contract with Mercury for The Penguins, and
decided to take The Platters with them in the deal. Mercury wanted The
Penguins, not necessarily The Platters, but Buck Ram insisted they take
both groups or none! The Platters signed a recording contract with Mercury
Records in 1955.
By 1956, Ram
had incorporated The Platters forming "The Five Platters, Inc." giving
each member stock in the corporation, with each member eventually signing
away his or her right to the name, The Platters, to the corporation, owned
by Ram. (In 1974, the California Superior Court found this original assignment
of rights back to Five Platters, Inc., and this original stock issued,
to be “illegal” and null)
In 1960, Williams
left The Platters to pursue his solo career with Reprise Records. He and
his wife, Helen, would later have their own group of Platters. Sonny Turner,
a Cleveland native, replaced Tony Williams as lead singer of The Platters.
By 1966, The Platters consisted of David Lynch, Herb Reed, Sonny Turner,
Nate Nelson, and Sandra Dawn. In 1969, the group parted ways with
their management. Buck Ram signed Monroe Powell to replace Sonny Turner,
an association which lasted for the next 25 years.
On Jan. 2,
1981 David Lynch died at the age of 52. June 2, 1989 Paul Robi passed away
at the age of 57, and on Aug. 7, 1992, Tony Williams died at the age of
64. This left only Herb Reed, who is still performing with his own group,
and Zola Taylor as living members of the ‘original’ Platters. After leaving
the group in the mid-1960s, California resident Zola Taylor eventually
would have her own Platters group, and unfortunately suffered a severe
stroke in recent years. 1990 brought the induction of the original Platters
into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Buck Ram passed away in 1991.
With this quick
synopsis of The Platters history comes a tangled web of information and
materials which is very important to both Platters history and their current
standing in the entertainment industry. It is said by many that there have
been between 8 and 120 music groups using The Platters name! How could
this be? One way in which this has happened is that after a legitimate
group member has left The Platters, they have started their own groups.
When members leave that ‘new’ group, they also might start their own. And
so grows the depening roots of controversy and confusion. Surely,
members that actually were with Buck Ram and The Platters should be allowed
to work... but can they reference themselves back to The Platters? The
courts have tried to clarify this on numerous occasions, and naturally
so have those currently performing. By outlining some of the most important
individuals related to The Platters, and some of the most recognized “Platters”
groups out there, we leave that question up to you. What is in black and
white is the fact that each individual related to The Platters and their
history is sincere in what they are doing, and truly believe in their rights.
For memorabilia collectors and fans of The Platters, the large number of
“Platters” visible to the public presents many opportunities to collect
momentos related to nearly 50 years of Platters history. All contact information
for these individuals will follow at the conclusion of this article.
Buck Ram, composer,
musical director, and producer, was the driving force behind the success
of The Platters. He originally pursuaded Mercury Records to sign them to
a record deal, and stuck with them until his death in 1991. He was a genius
song-writer, and is considered the mastermind behind The Platters hits.
Ram, who has been credited with writing nearly 1,000 songs, not only penned
such hits as “Only You,” “Smoke Gets In Your Eyes,” and “Twilight Time,”
for The Platters, but also wrote the hit “I’ll Be Home For Christmas” for
With over 200
personell changes in the Platters group over the years, it is evident that
what draws people to The Platters is their music, much of it written by
Ram, not necessarily the members of the group. In 1983, Ram told the Atlanta
Journal newspaper, “We’ve had 200 personell changes, and people do ask
about Tony (Williams) sometimes, but they never mention any of the other
guys except Monroe Powell, who’s been with us for 14 years.”
Born in Chicago,
IL, in 1909, Ram began his professional career as a lawyer, but was a saxophone
player at heart. He played with the legendary Benny Goodman and Gene Krupa
after he passed Illinois’ State Bar Exam, and soon began writing music
for many in the industry. He also is credited with discovering Ella Fitzgerald.
The story says that Ram practically dragged Chick Webb, a drummer he was
working with, into going to Harlem’s Apollo Theater where the 15 year old
Fitzgerald was performing. Eventually, the world would come to know her
as the First Lady of Jazz.
He then was
invited to Hollywood where he began writing music for motion pictures,
but found the industry to be very challenging.... so much so he was forced
to stop writing music altogether for 2 years. He chose to return to the
industry, a move that blessed the public with a sensational sound, and
a move that not only discovered, but in some ways, created The Three Suns
in the 1940s, The Platters in the 1950s, and The Union Gap in the 1960s.
Along the way, he garnered 16 Gold Records, and countless achievement awards.
Jean Bennett is considered
by many to have been Buck Ram’s “right hand woman.” Originally entering
the industry as an aspiring performer herself, Bennett soon became an employee
of Ram. With Ram and The Platters virtually from the beginning, Bennett
wrote and edited the first Personality Plugger in 1954. This publicity
paper was first released to disk jockeys, agents, magazines, and record
companies on February 15, 1954. By 1964, Bennett had moved to Las Vegas
from Los Angeles and purchased Personality Productions from Ram. Ram continued
to work very closely with Personality until his death in 1991.
a current co-worker of Bennett’s says, “She was the lady with The Platters.
Took the title of secretary for society to accept her. She was the lady
maintains her right to the Platters name is still valid and has her own
group, which is booked as The Buck Ram Platters, based out of Las Vegas.
Current members of this group include Tyrone Sweet, Julie Harris, Paul
Allen, III, Joel Gaines, and J. Michael Davis. While no original members
are in this group, J. Michael Davis did perform with The Platters during
the Ram era in the 1980s.
she and her company vigorously pursue groups which are illegally using
the Platters name. “We don’t feel it is right for people to take money
out of her mouth, or anybody else’s mouth,” says Hackett. At the same time,
Bennett has licensed two other groups to perform. A group located in Branson,
MO using the name of The World Famous Platters (members include Lawrence
Randell, Eddie Stoval, Walter White, and Dee Dee Hamilton) and a group
managed by Larry Marshack of New York, which often performs at Las Vegas’
Sahara Hotel & Casino, both perform with the approval of Bennett. “As
a last resort, I finally did license 2 or 3 different groups... they were
so popular and well liked.”
She also says
that an agreement has been reached with original member Herb Reed which
allows him to continue performing under the name, although Reed denied
any agreement between the two in a recent interview. “We get along fine...
but now he’s trying to go back on the agreement he gave with me, because
I settled with him out of court by giving him a license to perform as long
as he was able,” Bennett said.
In 1990, Martha
Robi (wife of Paul Robi), sued Bennett and Five Platters, Inc., and won
a total of $3,510,000. This court case also declared that three registered
trademarks of “The Platters,” which Five Platters, Inc. owned, be cancelled.
time, Bennett has continued to put on a very successful show with The Buck
Ram Platters, and continues to discourage the use of the name. “That’s
something we’re very, very adament about.” Bennett recently sued, and won
a judgement against, Monroe Powell, who was performing with the name The
Platters Featuring The Legendary Monroe Powell. She says that Powell refused
to sign a contract extension in the mid-1990s and left to perform with
his own group. “I put in a lot of years with him and it really breaks my
heart to have it turn into something like this.” Monroe maintains that
after the 1990 lawsuit between Robi and Bennett, Bennett sold the management
company to Mary Fanning, where he continued his employement with the Platters.
Bennett acknowledges that Powell’s statement is indeed true, but that the
company under Fanning’s direction ended operations all together. Bennett
maintains that her current Personality Productions company continues to
own all rights to The Platters name.
rulings have shown Bennett to have rights to the name, but several former
Platters vahemiently disagree with this idea. “Jean was there almost from
the conception of them, but she was secretary and then a partner to Buck
Ram. She feels she owns ‘The Platters.’ Just because you were in management,
how do you own The Platters?”, said Sonny Turner. Turner went on
to say, “I don’t know where she gets the power and authority to license
anyone.... at least my contribution has been significant to the Platters.”
It is evident
that Bennett has helped maintained a very successful and powerful company
over the years, but controversy remains over her right to use the name.
Along with Bennett, several others have also won ‘rights’ via the judicial
system. What is very clear, is that Bennett was ahead of her time in the
music industry. Some sources close to The Platters say Bennett was simply
a secretary, but the facts show she indeed purchased the management company
in the mid-1960s from Buck Ram. Sue Hackett says she, “Pioneered, really,
for me and other people a positive business world for women.... we are
where we are because of people like Jean Bennet.”
Hackett said, “No,
its not the original Platters, but where would they have been without Buck
Ram’s music... without people like Jean Bennett?” The Buck Ram Platters
are planning the release of a new album in 2000.
Herb Reed is
recognized as the founder of the original group, in both namesake and in
organization. (Bennett says Reed actually was not there from ‘day one,’
and says she has testimony from others to back her up. Most accounts show
that Reed was indeed the originator of the group.) Simply put, he said,
“I’m the guy who formed the Platters.” With Tony Williams, David Lynch,
Paul Robi, Zola Taylor, and himself, the Platters recorded hit after hit
record. With all the personell changes over the years, Herb Reed remained
the constant. The Platters started to walk on shaky ground after he left
The Platters in August of 1969, “The thing was, I got tired of every two
or three months...they were hiring someone new. I left to maintain the
quality and standards of the original group.”
Once he left
the group, he formed his own, which has continuously performed as Herb
Reed of The Original Platters and His Group, or a derivitive of the name.
This group currently features Reed, Billy Cox, William Newton, Wayne
Miller, and Valerie McIntosh, and can often be seen and heard performing
on cruise ships as well as other venues throughout the world. In
1998, the US 9th Curcuit Court of Appeals (San Franscisco, CA), upheld
a court decision giving Herb Reed the right to use the service mark “The
Platters” to the exclusion of one Martha Robi. Robi was the wife of former
Platters member Paul Robi, who had sued Reed for rights to the name. This
court case also reaffirmed that Five Platters, Inc., had not been reassigned
the rights to use The Platters name in 1956.
that after Reed left The Platters in 1969, he began performing in his own
group, using The Platters name, and Personality Productions sued, and won,
in Florida court to stop him from illegally performing.
Reed says that
other groups performing with the Platters name, “Have done tremendous damage
to the name and to me... if it doesn’t say Herb Reed, they’re all phonies.”
When asked how he felt about Jean Bennett’s Buck Ram Platters, Reed said,
“Believe me when I tell you, Jean Bennett was nothing more than my ex-manager’s
secretary. That’s all she was to us, and that’s all she’ll ever be to me
and the other original members. Nothing to do with the success of The Platters.”
said, “Herb Reed is the originator of The Platters and I think he has validity
to The Platters name... Jean does use ‘Buck Ram’s Platters,’ which is good.”
Wilson Williams, a member of Monroe Powell’s current group said, “We’ve
all got to respect Herb. He’s had to perform as ‘formerly of...’ for a
long time... and he created the name!”
Reed and his
group are very accomodating to fans, according to Herb, “I’ll definitely
autograph any photo that anyone sends.” For more information on Herb Reed
and his group, check out www.theplatters.com .
replaced Tony Williams as the lead singer of The Platters in 1960. From
1960 to 1964 the group lineup consisted of Sonny Turner, Herb Reed, Paul
Robi, David Lynch, and Zola Taylor.
As a teenager
growing up in Cleveland, Ohio, Turner performed with some friends of his
in a group called the Metrotones. Underage at the time, Turner used the
name Sonny Dinkes, and along with Melvin Smith, James Frierson, Leuvenia
Eaton, and Leonard Veal, The Metrotones signed their first recording contract
in late 1958 for Henry George’s Reserve record label.
In 1960, Sonny
was appearing in Cleveland, and at the same time a Los Angeles radio DJ,
Bill Crane, was helping Buck Ram recruit a replacement for Tony Williams,
who was leaving to pursue a solo career. Crane spotted Turner performing
at Cleveland’s Music Box, and liked what he heard. After recording a demo
tape the next day, and with Ram’s approval, Crane and Turner caught a night
sleeper train to Wisconsin where the Platters were performing, for an in-person
audition with the group. Eventually, out of over 100 prospects, 19 year
old Sonny Turner stepped into the lead role. He soon would become world
famous for his leads on “I Love You 1000 Times,” “With This Ring,” and
“Washed Ashore,” with The Platters. Herb Reed said, “Sonny Turner was extrememly
instrumental in helping me keep The Platters together. He and I were very
In 1965, Paul Robi
left the group for good.... never to perform again. After Herb Reed left
The Platters in 1969, Turner, too, decided he would leave the group for
a shot at a solo career. Today, Turner performs both his Sonny Turner Show,
as well as with Sonny Turner’s Platters, featuring Turner, James Austin
(who has also performed with Herb Reed), Morris Williams, Herb McQuay,
and Bernadette Miller. “I felt compelled to take my own legacy to get the
truth out.” Performing in Las Vegas lounges and throughout Japan and the
world, Turner puts on an excellent show, mixing in a blend of Motown and
He also has
several recordings under his own label, including Reflections of Sonny
Turner, and Sonny Turner By Request. “Reflections” includes a Stand By
Me medley, a Platters medley, and Turner’s original music. “By Request”
is an excellent CD full of Turner’s original works, a couple Platters
hits, aother. Also look for a “Sonny Turner’s Platters Live in Japan” CD
release in 2000. All of Turner’s albums are available through mail order
(via So-Turner, Inc.) and at repeat.com
Turner is very
active in monitoring groups using the Platters name, and is involved with
petitioning Congress for bills (see page 7) which protect the rights of
performers. “I still don’t like the idea that these supposedly licensed
groups can make a living on Platters music. I know people are hungry and
have to feed their families one way or the other, but let them create their
own legacy... they shouldn’t be taking credit for other performers’ work.”
accepts fan mail at the address provided, and both he and the rest of his
group enjoy signing autographs for their fans.
joined the Platters in 1970, after performing with such groups as The Ink
Spots and The Dominoes. A Personality press release states that it took
at least a year of cajoling him to join. A New York native, Powell is highly
trained in voice and opera singing. Upon the departure of lead singer Sonny
Turner, Powell was hired by Buck Ram to step into the role of lead singer
with The Platters. His employment with Personality Productions continued
until approximately 1995.
with The Platters is a story book in itself, as the longest standing member
to date. The current Las Vegas resident, while not an original Platter,
has been a mainstay for nearly 30 years. He was featured in national television
commercials for such companies as Schlitz Beer and Red Lobster. With the
Platters, he also appeared on the television programs The Dinah Shore Show,
The Mike Douglas Show, and others.
The singer says that
his career and relationship with Buck Ram and Personality Productions was
generally very good, and remained so until Ram passed away. Soon after
Rams death, and after a court verdict that awarded Martha Robi a large
sum of money from Jean Bennett and Personality Productions, Powell maintains
that Bennett actually sold Personality Productions to Mary Fanning, who
had been associated with the group for nearly 10 years. Powell says he
didn’t ever leave Jean Bennett or the group, but was in fact “only performing
with what she (Jean Bennett) had originally set up” for him. The dispute,
that has culminated in a lawsuit against Powell, began when Powell refused
a contract from Jean Bennett to leave the group, and join her again. Says
Bennett, “Monroe Powell refused to sign his contract in 1995 or 1996. Been
with me for 25 years, and he refused to sign it.”
group broke up with the departure of the management team, and several group
members. Kenn Johnson, who stuck by Powell, had been in correspondance
with Wilson Williams, and Powell recruited Wilson, Al Holland, and Verceal
Whitaker, all of the Top 40 show band, ‘Attraction,’ to round
out the lineup.
group, until recently, performing under the name ‘The Platters Featuring
The Legendary Monroe Powell’, features a very talented and energetic roster
of performers, who Powell says, “This is the best group I’ve been with.”
Williams recorded “Up The Downstairs” for ABC Records in 1978, before starting
his own record label in 1985. Detroit native Al Holland has experience
playing with many orchestras and symphonies, and today plays keyboard and
sings first tenor and baritone for Powell. Verceal Whitaker, prior to singing
with Powell and ‘Attraction’ sang with the Dawson Singers in Virginia and
with several recording artists.
A court document
dated October 12, 1999, shows that because of continued use of The Platters
name by Jean Bennett and Personality Productions/Five Platters, Inc., Monroe
Powell is no longer allowed to perform using a reference to The Platters
in promotion of concert dates or selling of merchandise. Powell and RoeWil
Entertainment, co-defendants in the lawsuit, maintain that Bennett has
not had continuous use of the name, as Bennett sold the businesses after
the Robi lawsuit, and are appealing the verdict.
that he has never tried to take money out of the hands of others, and acknowledges
Herb Reed and Sonny Turner as legitimate former members who should be allowed
to perform, in addition to himself.
lost rights to the name when she lost that case to Martha Robi, and maybe
never had them. Now she’s writing our venues and they’re beginning to be
scared of us.” In his own humble and quiet way, Powell says, “All those
years I was loyal to them... I could have left. I just want to work, to
continue on, that’s all I’ve ever done.” Both Wilson and Powell say they
really don’t care if legitimate former members are performing, they just
feel they have a right to continue in their profession, “We’d gladly use
‘Formerly of’ or something similar, just waiting to see what the courts
will allow us to do.”
member Lolita Fonza-McCallister, Platters member from 1971 to 1978, says
of Monroe, “At first he was hard to get to know, very private. But after
I had been with the group for awhile I found him to be very personable.
As a professional, there was none better than him when it came to singing!
He had then, and probably has now, charisma. I thought he would always
be with Jeanie!” For the record, while Fonza had several differences with
Jean Bennett, Buck Ram, and a particular member of the group at the time
which led to her leaving The Platters, she says, “My time with The Platters
was very enjoyable. I was young, single, and it was very fun!”
also had positive words to say about Powell, “I think Monroe should be
working, and I think he’s a very talented guy and also a nice man. I get
along with him pretty well, and I’d like to see him make a living.”
said in a recent interview, “This is all a mess. It certainly isn’t what
meets the eye when talking to one individual. The truth needs to come out.
If there’s something not so favorable about our group... so be it! Put
it in print.”
each member of this group will gladly autograph any items you send to them.
Powell says, “Many people remember me as a Platter because I signed so
many autographs. It’s very important to do things like that for your fans.”
Until recently, they also sold autographed copies of their recordings and
low-cost signed photos... though the courts have said they must now stop
that practice. Once their new name has been finalized, look for a new selection
of autographed merchandise which complies to the court’s request.
THE STORY CONTINUES
battles and a diversity of Platters groups have plagued the name in the
United States, it is fact that Herb Reed, Sonny Turner, and Monroe Powell
all have a legitimate history with The Platters. Recent courts have found
Jean Bennett and Personality Productions to have rights to The Platters
name. At the same time, virtually all parties involved have sued one another
and various times, and have won “rights” along the way.
to those outlined above, other Platters groups are still performing. For
example, Bernard Purdie (not the famous drummer) currently has a “Bernard
Purdie Salutes The Platters” show. It is said that Purdie was originally
hired by Buck Ram, but not to perform with The Platters, although that
was his personal ambition. He ended up being an MC for the shows, before
becoming disenchanted and leaving. Purdie, formerly with the recording
group The Avalons, then started his own Platters group and eventually was
sued by Ram to discontinue performing using the name. Today, Purdie, along
with Billy Lee Hughes, George Cox, and Laurie Anderson (wife of Gary Anderson
of Gary U.S. Bonds) perform their “salute” throughout the United States
and Canada, as they have since 1985. Jean Bennett told us, “Bernard Purdie
was originally hired to start a Flairs group.... he never was a Platter.”
Ella Woods also tours with a group of ‘Platters’ overseas. No matter who’s
“side you’re on,” Sonny Turner summed up some of the unscroupulous actions
by rival groups with these words, “It’s about money, not about integrity.”
He reiterated that the legitimate former performers just need to be careful
and use a name such as “Formerly of,” or “Salutes” The Platters. “Let’s
face it, there are no more Platters. Everyone’s either passed away or parted
in their own direction. Why not pay tribute to wonderful music in a dignified
While the Platters
have divided over the years and members have come and gone, the one thing
that remains contant is the beauty of their music, still performed today
by the legendary Monroe Powell, Sonny Turner, Herb Reed, and others...albeit
using different groups.
For over 45
years, The Platters music has brought joy to the millions of us that have
heard it. Hearing of lawsuits over the right to the name, and of the right
to perform between the actual members themselves and former management,
is a sound that isn’t so sweet. Is it even possible to imagine an all-star
lineup consisting of Reed, Turner, and Powell . . . maybe even managed
and promoted by Bennett?! Probably not, but one would hope an agreement
could be reached that would satisfy the interests of all parties involved.
Regardless, many groups currently are performing that have no ties to The
Platters in any way. As a fan, don’t let smoke get in your eyes!!
information on all The Platters groups performing today, check out http://go.to/Platters
. We will keep you updated on concert/tour information, court procedings,
merchandise that is available, and so much more! As there are far too many
details and facts to outline in one magazine article on The Platters, we
hope to continue following this case closely here. Also, keep on the lookout
for a book to be released on The Platters in the coming year, from The
Archive - http://go.to/ArchiveNews -
The Archive News would like
to thank Herb Reed, Sonny Turner, Monroe Powell, Jean Bennett, and others
mentioned, for spending so much time with the author for this article.
They all were very generous with documents, photos, and their personal
stories of The Platters. Also thanks to the same for their ever important
contribution to The Platters, and a lifetime of wonderful music.
This article is dedicated
to the memory of Buck Ram.